A Thai Scotswoman in Glasgow is in contact with her lawyers in Thailand after a the Appeals Court set aside the death sentence handed down for the premeditated murder of her 64-year-old father and his devoted Thai wife, her mother, in an appalling and callous double murder in Phrae province on Tuesday the 18th September 2018.

The 33-year-old daughter of 64-year-old Alan Hogg and his 61-year-old wife Nott, who were both brutally murdered in September 2018 by Mr Hogg’s brother in law and two hired hitmen, is to appeal a decision this week which saw the death sentence on the three men, imposed in May last year, lifted.

33-year-old Robyn Hogg said she will appeal the latest court decision to set aside the death sentence on her parent’s murderers imposed by Phrae Provincial Court in 2019. This includes her father’s brother in law and two hired hitmen.

A 33-year-old Scottish woman has vowed to appeal against a decision that emerged this week by a Thai Court of Appeal to set aside the death sentence in respect of the murder of her wealthy 64-year-old father Alan Hogg and his faithful 61 year old Thai wife Nott Hogg in September 2018.

In May last year, a Thai provincial court in Phrae province, northern Thailand, sentenced the three men to death for the murder of the loving pair who were married in Edinburgh in 1986 and who had lived happily in Thailand since the late nineties and on a full-time basis since 2014. 

Wealthy petrochemical engineer developed a luxurious mansion and extended property in Phrae

Mr Hogg had built an elaborate and well-appointed mansion in the province including a swimming pool. The pair were known to be well off.

Mr Hogg had worked offshore in the construction industry. He was a petrochemical engineer. He also owned a laundry business in Scotland.

Brother in law masterminded the murders 

One of the three men condemned for his death was his brother in law, 64-year-old Warut Satchakit, who masterminded the murder of the pair.

It is understood that Mr Warut had grown an intense hatred for his Scottish brother-in-law who regularly upbraided him for borrowing money from his sister. Mr Warut lived in a wooden shack on the demesne of his in-laws. 

This hatred grew out of control after 2014 when Mr Hogg retired to Thailand with his wife to live full-time in the kingdom.

Trigger for the rage and murder was when the killer’s sister told him that he must leave

It was reported that investigating police discovered that the trigger that drove Mr Warut over the edge was the insistence, in late 2018, by his younger sister that he begin to move out of the estate altogether where he had worked for the couple for twenty years.

Read the full story of the atrocious murder of a loving Scots Thai couple here

Mr Warut went to a friend, a man named Mr Suma Utpamoon, and confided in him his murderous plan.

Mr Suma refused point-blank to have anything to do with the murder when he heard that the Thai man planned to have his sister killed. 

Introduced to two unscrupulous hitmen

He did, unfortunately, recommend Mr Warut to two hitmen who were less scrupulous.

25-year-old Kittipong ­Kamwan and 64-year-old Phia Kamsai were paid ฿50,000 by Mr Warut. They expeditiously and brutally carried out the double murder. 

Mr Hogg was shot dead within the grounds of his home while his wife was hit over the head with a car wrench.

Nott was bludgeoned to death, according to police, by her own brother as she suffered his pent up rage in a garage within the home after her husband had been already gunned down.

The couple were buried together with their bodies disposed of in a 6 feet hole near the property’s duck pond. The hit squad used a digger to bury the pair and cover them over.

This all happened in the space of a few hours on the 18th September 2018, a Tuesday.

Police quickly solve the crime

Police were alerted to the crime after the couple failed to turn up at a meeting in Chiang Mai with close friends.

They quickly discovered the disappearance of Mr Hogg’s new Ford pickup sold off by Mr Warut for ฿420,000 in cash.

A police search team with sniffer dogs soon unearthed this foulest of crimes.

Death sentence handed down in May last year

The crime was solved quite quickly.

In May last year, the brother in law and his two hired hitmen received the death sentence while Mr Warut’s friend Mr Suma was sentenced to 25 years in prison for assisting the plot.

Thai Scotswwoman determined to appeal the latest judgment and see the death sentence reimposed

Late this week, the murdered pair’s Thai Scots daughter, Robyn, was determined to see the death sentence re-imposed.

She told the popular Scottish Daily Record newspaper that she was still trying to clarify the decision of the Thai Appeals Court but that she had been assured by her lawyers in at home that she can appeal the decision to the Supreme Court which will have the ultimate say in the matter at that point, at least in law.

Robyn, a businesswoman like her father, now lives in Glasgow. 

‘We’re not happy about it’

‘The death ­sentences were retracted, we only found out about it last week,’ she revealed. ‘I’m speaking to my lawyer to get a better picture of what’s ­happening. I’m told we have time to appeal.’

Ms Hogg expressed her displeasure with the outcome but was not giving up her fight to attain justice for her father and mother.

‘It’s difficult. We’re not happy about it. We are getting mixed messages from the Thai courts. We don’t know if it’s one sentence or all the sentences.’

Join the Thai News forum, follow Thai Examiner on Facebook here
Receive all our stories as they come out on Telegram here
Follow Thai Examiner here

Further reading:

Death sentence for murderous trio who executed a loving Thai wife and her UK husband in Phrae

Death sentence imposed on school boss who murdered a 2-year-old boy in a gold shop robbery in January

School director pleads guilty in court to murder and other charges after Lopburi shopping centre massacre

Master of lies and death, the gold shop killer’s life, actions and motives probed by police as wife flees

Lopburi child killer is a primary school director who murdered 3 people this month just for kicks

All quiet in Lopburi as fears grow that the gold shop killer may have slipped the police arrest net – media blamed

Mum’s heartbreak after 2 year old’s murder as police now know the identity of the cruel and evil killer

2-year-old shot dead by gold robber Thursday night as 3 die, 4 injured in mass shooting with silencer gun

Party over for 45 year old composed armed robber who took ฿4 million in Bangkok gold shop raid

Police near closing the ฿9 million gold robbery case in Khon Kaen as the last suspect returns

Convictions of Burmese Koh Tao murderers and death sentences upheld by Thai Supreme Court

Koh Tao victim’s family endorse the conviction of Myanmar migrants

Koh Tao claims by UK teenager questioned by Thai police – arrest warrants indicated for some media

Australian man pleads for help for his son and Thai wife sentenced to death for failed drug trafficking plot at sea

Police to re-arrest Australian death row inmate after he is released under court order at Bangkwang prison

93% of Thai people want to see the death penalty put to use to curb shocking murders and drug gangs